If you’re looking for some of the best sandwiches NJ has to offer, look no further than Tony Boys. This is one name that consistently rises above all the other sandwich shops in the area. They have multiple locations and a mouthwatering menu full of flavor-packed sandwiches. In fact, Tony Boys almost has a cult following among foodies, families, and lunch break regulars throughout the Garden State.

On the menu, you can find some of the best cold sandwiches in NJ, including many specialties like their iconic chicken and eggplant cutlet creations, and more. This isn’t just another deli. It’s a go to destination for serious sandwich lovers. Wondering what sets them apart from the competition? Check out these 7 delicious reasons why Tony Boys serves some of the best sandwiches NJ has available.

1. Signature Chicken Cutlet Sandwiches That Hit Every Time

You simply cannot go wrong with the fan favorite – the chicken cutlet sandwich. This is so much more than just some crispy chicken on a slice of bread. It’s a legendary and well known sandwich that you simply can’t resist. Every cutlet is freshly breaded and fried to perfection. Then that freshly made cutlet is layered with premium ingredients like mozzarella, roasted red peppers, arugula, or balsamic glaze.

The best part is, you can have a simple, classic chicken, cutlet sandwich, or you can choose from one of their creative variations, like The Parma or the Fat Tony. No matter which one you choose, there’s something uniquely satisfying about every bite.

2. Fresh, House Made Ingredients Make All the Difference

Building a good sandwich isn’t just haphazardly throwing a few ingredients together. It’s crafting a sandwich made with care that perfectly blends all the right flavors together. At Tony Boys, they take this very seriously. From eggplant cutlet sandwiches NJ to some of the best cold sandwiches NJ has to offer, every sandwich is carefully pieced together.

The sandwich shop uses house made sauces, hand-sliced meats, fresh veggies, and perfectly baked bread. This applies to every single sandwich made with love. A lot of sandwich shops out there use prepackaged shortcuts. But Tony Boys believes that delivering truly fresh and flavorful experiences with each order makes a huge difference. And customers can taste that difference in every bite.

3. Cold Sandwiches That Redefine the Deli Standard

When it comes to cold sandwiches in NJ, Tony Boys raises the bar. Their classic subs are anything but ordinary, and they often feature premium deli meats, aged cheeses, and other custom toppings that bring bold flavor without the need to heat the sandwich for it to be delicious. The shop has many local favorites, including the Italian Stallion, the Honey Turkey, and the Gobbler. These cold sandwiches prove that you don’t have to stick to the basics for something cool and delicious. The best part is that there are options for every preference.

The shop has so many different choices, Including turkey, roast beef, ham, salami, and veggie packed builds. They show us that a cold sandwich can be just as crave worthy as a hot one. Plus, you get fresh baked bread that holds up from the very first bite to the very last bite. This is sure to be a cold sandwich experience that is satisfying and totally unforgettable.

4. Eggplant Cutlet Sandwiches NJ Residents Rave About

Don’t miss another standout option on the Tony Boys menu. Their eggplant cutlet sandwiches are another top fan favorite. This one is vegetarian friendly, and it’s a masterpiece that has earned some serious praise from both meat eaters, and non-meat eaters alike.

For this sandwich, the eggplant is breaded and fried until it is golden brown. Then, it is layered with delicious ingredients like fresh mozzarella, marinara, and basil. It is most commonly served on warm ciabatta bread or a signature sandwich roll. This is a classic Italian style sandwich and it’s absolutely one of the best options you can get your hands on.

5. Creative Combos That Break the Mold

Tony Boys isn’t afraid to push the sandwich envelope, and that is how you get so many creative sandwiches that are utterly delicious. This is perhaps one of the biggest compliments we can give the sandwich shop. They certainly know how to nail the classics, but they are also well known for a bold and inventive combos that you’re not going to find anywhere else.

Consider sandwiches like the Jersey Devil. This specialty sandwich is made with a chicken cutlet, bacon, and spicy mayo. Or perhaps you would be interested in the Brooklyn Bomber. This delicious combo is stacked with prosciutto, sharp provolone, and balsamic glaze. These sandwiches show a perfect balance of texture and flavor, while also displaying the creativity behind the culinary team here.

Every time you go to Tony Boys, you get a chance to discover something new or even experiment with flavor packed combinations that bring a modern twist to timeless deli Staples.

6. Convenient Online Ordering and Multiple NJ Locations

You can find Tony Boys spread out throughout New Jersey. It’s a franchise sandwich shop, which means that while it has a unique style, you don’t always have to travel to taste it. This makes it easy to satisfy your sandwich cravings no matter where you are in North Jersey. They have locations and Madyson, Livingston, and Florham Park. Each shop has seamless online ordering solutions, which means it’s never been more convenient to grab your favorite sub or special sandwich.

You can order lunch for the office, feed a family on the go, or even pick up dinner after a long day at work. Tony Boys takes the stress out of sandwich orders, allowing you to order ahead online and choose your pick up location so you can get back to your day.

7. Rave Reviews and a Loyal Local Following

Finally, you can ask anyone in Morris or Essex County where to find the best sandwiches and their answer will likely be Tony Boys. Those local fans, paired with consistently high ratings and positive reviews online, clearly show us the sandwich shop has earned it place among the best.

Final Thoughts

If you’re looking for the best sandwiches NJ has to offer, this is it. Tony Boys clearly stands out because they offer something truly special on many different levels. From perfectly crisped chicken cutlet sandwiches to satisfying cold sandwiches and even their vegetarian eggplant cutlets and more, this shop has mastered the art of delicious sandwiches. Go ahead and place your order and taste all the hype is about.