When it comes to cutlet sandwiches that NJ residents truly love, Tony Boy’s Sandwich House delivers a lineup that’s both creative and crave-worthy.

From time-honored Italian-style chicken cutlet sandwiches to inventive takes featuring peanut butter, coleslaw, or vodka sauce, every item on their menu is packed with flavor and personality.

Whether you’re into traditional sandwiches or searching for the best eggplant cutlet sandwiches NJ can offer, Tony Boy’s makes every bite a standout.

Let’s take a look at some of the best cutlet sandwiches NJ has to offer.

12 Best Cutlet Sandwiches in New Jersey

1. Number 10

A fan-favorite among cutlet sandwiches in NJ, the Number 10 from Tony Boy’s nails the balance between savory and sweet.

A juicy sandwich gets dressed with roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, and a light balsamic drizzle, giving it that Italian deli appeal locals rave about.

Whether you’re craving your first or your fiftieth chicken cutlet sandwich, this one satisfies on every level with quality ingredients and bold, clean flavor.

2. Parmesan

If you’re searching for hearty, old-school comfort, this is one of the best in NJ.

Choose between crispy chicken or perfectly fried eggplant cutlets, slathered in rich marinara and topped with oozy melted mozzarella.

The eggplant cutlet option in particular is a great pick for vegetarians seeking something indulgent and robust, making this a go-to for fans of traditional Italian-American fare.

3. Drunk Chicken

Tony Boy’s spin on a vodka parm sandwich, the Drunk Chicken, takes the humble sandwich to another level, making it one of, if not the best cutlet sandwich NJ.

A tender, breaded cutlet is soaked in creamy, tomato-rich vodka sauce and finished with fresh mozzarella.

If you’re looking for a way to elevate your usual lunch order into something decadent and unique, this is the sandwich that’ll get you buzzed on flavor alone.

4. Cordon Bleu

Inspired by the classic French dish, Tony Boy’s Cordon Bleu delivers a golden chicken cutlet layered with honey ham, melted Swiss, and a generous spread of honey mustard.

The sweet-and-savory mix of sharp cheese, rich meat, and crisp cutlet makes this one of the most unique cutlet sandwiches around.

It’s elegant and indulgent, perfect for sandwich lovers who want a little class with their crunch, making this one of the best cutlet sandwiches in NJ.

5. Chipotle

Heat lovers, take note: the Chipotle cutlet sandwich is here to wake up your taste buds.

A golden, breaded chicken cutlet gets topped with melted provolone, jalapeños, and a zesty chipotle mayo that packs just the right amount of smoky kick.

It’s a bold pick that foodies crave, offering spicy satisfaction in every bite. If you like your sandwiches to come with a little fire, this one delivers.

6. Stallone

As tough and bold as its namesake, the Stallone sandwich is a heavy-hitter and is considered one of the best cutlet sandwiches in NJ.

It layers a chicken cutlet with pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, and a drizzle of olive oil for added richness. The pepperoni adds a salty, spicy kick that complements the juicy cutlet and cheese.

It’s like a tasty, high-protein offspring of a pizza and a sandwich. It’s a great choice for anyone who enjoys strong, meaty flavors.

7. Lumpy

Lumpy is a fun name for a seriously good sandwich. This one goes all-in with a chicken cutlet, crispy bacon, mozzarella, creamy coleslaw, and Thousand Island dressing.

It’s one of the more playful sandwiches NJ locals enjoy, a little messy, a lot flavorful. The combination of crunch, salt, and tang makes every bite something new.

If you’re not afraid to get a little sauce on your fingers, Lumpy is one for the books.

8. Calzone

This sandwich is a hybrid of a handheld feast and an Italian entrée, the best of both.

You can choose either a chicken or eggplant cutlet, both popular options among cutlet sandwiches fans, and it’s paired with ricotta, ham, mozzarella, and a side of marinara.

It’s full of meat and dairy, savory, and rich. The eggplant cutlet version is especially worth trying if you’re into vegetarian sandwiches that still offer serious indulgence.

9. The Murph

Rustic and zesty, The Murph offers either a chicken or eggplant cutlet base topped with sautéed peppers and onions, finished with a punchy balsamic glaze.

It’s a no-fuss, full-flavor choice that’s great for anyone exploring eggplant cutlet sandwiches, though the chicken cutlet version is equally strong.

This sandwich is for fans of roasted veggie flavor paired with a hearty base, it tastes like something your Italian grandma would’ve made if she had a sandwich press.

10. West Coast

The West Coast is a fresh, creamy take on the classic chicken cutlet style sandwich.

The texture contrast is outstanding, crunchy outside, creamy inside, and it’s one of the more modern sandwiches NJ has to offer.

If you’re a fan of club sandwiches or BLTs, you’ll appreciate how this one brings that vibe but with more flavor and heft.

11. Chop Chop

The Chop Chop offers a full chopped salad, romaine, olives, onion, tomato, and balsamic vinaigrette, layered with grilled or cutlet chicken on a sub roll.

It’s a great way to sneak some greens into your sandwich without losing the satisfaction that comes with one of the best sandwiches NJ diners can get.

 Crunchy, tangy, and refreshing, this one hits all the right notes.

12. Nutty Pig

The Nutty Pig is one of the quirkiest and tastiest chicken cutlet sandwiches in NJ.

A fried chicken cutlet gets topped with bacon, peanut butter, and jelly for a sweet-salty combo that works shockingly well. It’s indulgent, sticky, and flavorful in the best way possible.

If you love comfort food that surprises you, this chicken cutlet style sandwich is a must.

Conclusion

Tony Boy’s doesn’t just serve sandwiches, it defines what cutlet sandwiches are all about, there is a reason they’re known for serving the best cutlet sandwich in NJ.

With expertly crafted chicken cutlet sandwiches and flavorful eggplant cutlet options, their menu satisfies classic tastes and adventurous cravings alike.

Each bite showcases premium ingredients and bold flavor combinations. For anyone searching for top-tier chicken or eggplant cutlet sandwiches NJ style, Tony Boy’s is a must-visit.