How we got here…

Crazy as it sounds, Tony Boy’s was never really the plan. But, having both parents in the food business I inevitably knew I would end up here. In 2013 I opened a full-service restaurant (Marra’s Restaurant in Livingston, NJ). As the years went on, I kept noticing this little storefront three doors down that had remained vacant. Four years later, I figured I would give it a try and just open up a few hours a day for lunch and sell some sandwiches and salads.

I wanted to be different and offer things that were fun, interesting and unique, while also taking classic sub-shop staples and making them the way I like to eat them. The concept was well received and I quickly realized this was going to be more than a little sub-shop open a few hours a day.

In 2020 a second location was opened in Madison, NJ After expanding the menu and the operating hours.

In February 2024, we opened our third location in Montville, NJ.

I could not be more grateful for the support of these three towns and all the surrounding areas. My pledge will always be to serve you with the same standards I would want for myself. In other words… I will make it for you as if it were for me!

That’s my promise.

-Anthony Marra Jr.